If you’re at all familiar with the pattern of defensiveness, you might be thinking:
“Great. So my brain overreacts, my body joins in, and my behaviour follows. Excellent system.”
Fair.
The good news is: defensiveness isn’t something you have to fight, suppress, or “fix” through sheer willpower. In fact, trying to force it away usually makes it louder.
Defensiveness softens through safety – specifically, creating enough internal safety that you don’t need to immediately protect yourself in moments that feel uncomfortable.
So the goal isn’t to get rid of defensiveness; it’s to change your relationship with it.
From: automatic reaction
To: something you can notice, understand, and choose how to respond to
It’s Less About Control, More About Capacity
This isn’t about becoming perfectly calm or endlessly patient (no one is, despite what certain podcasts may suggest).
It’s about increasing your capacity to tolerate things like:
- discomfort
- uncertainty
- feeling slightly exposed
- the mild sting of “hmm, maybe I didn’t get that quite right”
The more capacity you have for those experiences, the less your system needs to jump straight into protection mode.
And that’s where things start to shift.
A Practical Way In: Four Useful Moves
You don’t need a complicated system for this. A simple way to think about it is through four overlapping skills:
awareness, integration, regulation, and behaviour
(Yes, those sound a bit formal. Stay with me – they’re actually very practical.)
1. Awareness: Catch It Early (Ideally Before the Verbal Essay Begins)
The first shift is simply noticing defensiveness as it’s happening.
Not ten minutes later, or ruminating over it in the shower that evening.
In the moment.
You might catch:
- the urge to interrupt
- the thought “that’s not fair”
- the sudden need to explain everything immediately
- your jaw tightening or your shoulders lifting
That’s your cue:
“Ah. Something in me feels under threat.”
You don’t need to stop it instantly. Just noticing it already creates a bit of space.
And that space is where choice lives.
2. Integration: Acknowledge What’s Actually Going On
Once you’ve noticed it, the next move is surprisingly simple:
acknowledge the internal experience.
Something like:
- “Part of me feels criticised right now.”
- “This is hitting a bit.”
- “I feel slightly exposed.”
This isn’t about agreeing with the feedback or taking blame.
It’s about recognising:
“This reaction makes sense, given how it feels.”
When you do that, something important happens – the need to defend often drops slightly, because the part of you that felt under threat is no longer being ignored.
3. Regulation: Get Your Body Back on Your Side
At this point, your body is probably still a bit activated.
And trying to think your way out of that rarely works.
So instead, do something very simple:
slow things down physically.
- Take a slightly longer exhale
- Unclench your jaw (it’s probably clenched – it’s always the jaw!)
- Drop your shoulders a fraction
- Pause before speaking
You don’t need to become completely calm. You’re just aiming to take the edge off.
Think of it as moving from “ready to argue a case in court” to “able to have a conversation without cross-examining anyone.”
4. Behaviour: Choose a Different Way to Respond
Once there’s a bit more space, you can respond differently.
Not by abandoning your perspective – but by expanding how you engage.
A surprisingly powerful move is simply to listen fully.
Let the other person finish.
(Yes, even if you already have a very good response prepared.)
Then try something like:
- “I want to understand what you mean – can you say more?”
- “Okay, I hear that. Let me think about it for a second.”
These kinds of responses do two things:
- They reduce the sense of conflict
- They give your nervous system more time to settle
And importantly, they keep the conversation collaborative rather than adversarial.
The Slightly Uncomfortable Bit: Not Defending Immediately
This is often the hardest part.
Choosing not to jump in, justify, or correct right away can feel… risky.
Like you’re leaving something unresolved.
Or allowing a misunderstanding to exist for too long.
But staying in that space (even briefly) creates a new kind of experience:
One where:
- you don’t collapse
- the conversation doesn’t explode
- and nothing terrible actually happens
Over time, those experiences update your system.
The Bigger Shift: From Protection to Participation
As you practise this, something gradually changes.
You still feel the initial defensive pull (that doesn’t vanish overnight) but it becomes less dominant.
Less convincing or urgent.
You start to:
- pause instead of react
- listen without immediately preparing a defence
- stay present in slightly uncomfortable moments
And conversations start to feel… easier.
Maybe not perfect, or conflict-free… but more manageable, more open, and a lot less like a subtle debate competition.
What This Changes (Beyond Just Conversations)
Relationally, this shift is huge.
There’s more room for:
- repair
- honesty
- different perspectives
- actual understanding
People feel heard. You feel less under attack.
And internally, something shifts too.
You start relating to yourself with more awareness and less automatic protection.
Less “defend at all costs,” more “let’s see what’s actually happening here.”
Final Thought
Working with defensiveness isn’t about becoming passive, agreeable, or endlessly calm.
It’s about becoming steady enough that you don’t have to protect yourself from every uncomfortable moment.
It’s about staying open without losing yourself.
And over time, the thing that once felt like a threat – feedback, disagreement, being seen – becomes something you can actually work with.
Maybe not always comfortably.
But at least without immediately assembling a full legal defence team in your head.
Want to work with this pattern more closely? Take the ‘pay what you can’ YouTube workshop…
…or grab access to the mini-course here.
Join my growing community on Instagram @DrMaddieSmith
© 2026 Dr Madeleine Smith. All rights reserved.